In what ways does Foster address the tension between historical traditions and the contemporary drive toward individual autonomy? Consider how his approach to the disciplines (fasting, solitude, etc.) resonates with or challenges the highly independent nature of contemporary Western societies.

Examine Foster’s treatment of joy and freedom throughout the book, particularly how celebration becomes the culmination of the spiritual disciplines. Why might Foster position celebration at the end of the text? Explore whether his emphasis on celebration provides a practical framework for avoiding legalism and burnout in spiritual formation.

Compare Foster’s use of personal anecdotes and historical Christian examples to reveal a continuity of discipline. How does his employment of diverse sources influence the reader’s view of the disciplines as universal? Are there gaps, whether historical or cultural, that might weaken his argument?