Content Warning: This section includes discussions of animal euthanasia.

When Dorothy opens the door, she sees that two animal control officers are outside. Peachie has lodged a complaint against Riley. The officers say they have to take Riley back to the animal shelter until a decision is made about what to do with him. Riley might have to be euthanized because the law in Oregon says that any dog that chases livestock must be put down. Dorothy tries to explain that they are planning on taking Riley to an animal psychiatrist, but the officers insist that it is too late. They have to take Riley immediately. William is distraught. Douglas goes to get Riley, and William unsuccessfully tries to stop him. The officers take Riley away, and William locks himself in his room, crying.

William comes back downstairs before his father leaves. Dorothy wonders if they can submit an appeal for Riley since he chased the horse but did not actually bite him. However, William’s father points out that the law specifically says that chasing livestock is enough of a reason to put a dog down. William hopes that he can convince Peachie to change her mind and forgive Riley.